25

So I see "vel", "aut", and "-ve" being used (mostly) interchangeably in the Latin I read. Is there any idiomatic difference, or can they be used interchangeably?

For example, is it valid Latin (and does it have the right meaning) if I use "-ve" for either/or, like I would with "aut"?

Licet tibi habere aut vim aut laetitia

Licet tibi habere vimve laetitiave

And does using "vel" instead of "aut" change the meaning in any way?

Licet tibi habere vel vim vel laetitia

  • 2
    When I read the title I kept thinking that there is a big difference between aut, vel, and -ve versus et cetera. – tox123 Jul 11 '16 at 1:21
19

Simply, vel is inclusive and aut is exclusive. As Lewis and Short put it:

In general aut puts in the place of a previous assertion another, objectively and absolutely antithetical to it, while vel indicates that the contrast rests upon subjective opinion or choice; i. e. aut is objective, vel subjective, or aut excludes one term, vel makes the two indifferent.

&

[Vel] As disjunctive conjunction, to introduce an alternative as a matter of choice or preference, or as not affecting the principal assertion (while aut introduces an absolute or essential opposition...

Going off your examples:

Licet tibi habere aut vim aut laetitiam.

This means, "You are allowed to have either power or happiness but not both."

Licet tibi habere vel vim vel laetitiam.

"You are allowed to have power, or perhaps happiness, or both, should you wish."

The enclitic -ve is the same as vel.

Bennett's example I think is more illustrative:

quī aethēr vel caelum nōminātur, which is called aether or heaven

That is, both aether and caelum as the name for the sky is correct.

So in your example, aut is the best word to use.

9

I'll just add that there's another word for "or," sive (or seu). It's used to mean "also known as" or to indicate that the speaker is indifferent as to which option is chosen.

Si media nox est sive est prima vespera . . .
Tamen est eundum quo imperant.

Whether it's the middle of the night or early evening . . .
Still, you have to go where they order you.

Plautus Curculio 1.1

I always feel kind of bad for sive, as if it were the redheaded stepchild of disjunctions.

  • 2
    sive, a contraction of si and vi, means "or if". It's not really synonymous with vel. – Geremia Aug 14 '16 at 21:20
  • I'm confused—isn't that exactly what this answer says? – Joel Derfner Aug 14 '16 at 21:37
  • "media nox" isn't another word for "prima vespera". I don't see how you could use "vel" in your example. – Geremia Aug 14 '16 at 22:03
  • @Geremia Sive often means simply "or" in Late Latin texts, especially to indicate a subtitle of a book or another name for something. See section C under Lewis and Short. – C. M. Weimer Mar 28 '17 at 23:40
  • @C.M.Weimer Yes, L&S §C of "sive" says it's disjunctive, but interestingly it says vel was sometimes used in a "purely disjunctive sense," so there is some evolution in these "or" words. – Geremia Mar 29 '17 at 15:04

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.