3

This excerpt comes from lines 138-139 of chapter VIII of the 2003 edition of Lingua latina per se illustrata:

      Quis saccum portat? Servus saccum portat. Quī servus? Servus quī saccum portat est Syrus. Is/ille servus saccum portat.

In the right hand side of the page, there is the following explanation:

is servus = ille servus

I believe there is an error in such explanation and this should be

is = ille servus

because is is a pronoun that can indeed be replaced by ille servus. Is my interpretation correct or am I missing something?

1 Answer 1

5

"Is servus" is not an error.

Latin "pronouns"* don't work like English pronouns. Is can be used by itself, but it can also be used adjectivally with a noun. The same goes for ille, iste and hic.

Lewis and Short covers this type of use in section B:

Esp. 1 In connection with a noun: ea re, quia turpe sit, faciendum non esse, Cic. Off. 3, 13: ea res ut est Helvetiis enuntiata, etc., Caes. B. G. 1, 4: ne ob eam rem tribueret, etc., id. ib. 1, 13: flumen est Arar ... id flumen, etc., id. ib. 1, 12: sub id tempus, Liv. 43, 5, 3: ejus disputationis sententias memoriae mandavi, Cic. Lael. 1, 3: ante eam diem, id. Att. 2, 11, 2: ea tempestate, Sall. C. 36, 4: quam urbem is rex condidit, Plin. 6, 17, 21, § 61.—

"Is servus" and "ille servus" are not actually interchangeable in general, but both are grammatical.

*I put this in scare quotes because linguists often consider Latin to have no true third-person pronouns.

4
  • 1
    So is, ea, id can work as demonstrative adjectives?
    – Charo
    Sep 28, 2023 at 12:59
  • 3
    @Charo Correct. Demonstrative pronouns in Latin are also equally demonstrative adjectives.
    – cmw
    Sep 28, 2023 at 13:24
  • @Charo, not only is/ea/id, but also ille/-a/-ud, iste/-a/-ud, hic/haec/hoc, etc. Sep 28, 2023 at 14:09
  • 1
    Yes, of course, @KotobaTrilyNgian: I knew the demonstrative adjectives-pronouns you mention. But I didn't know that is, ea, id can also be used as demonstrative adjectives. I'm a beginner in Latin.
    – Charo
    Sep 28, 2023 at 14:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.