5

In Mt. 19:14, "άρσεν και θήλυ" means "male and female".

In music terminology ἄρσις means a stressed/emphasized sound, and θέσις the corresponding unstressed one.

Is ἄρσις etymologically related to άρσεν (male = active sex) and θέσις etymologically related to θήλυ (female = passive sex)?

7

What a coincidence, but they're actually unrelated.

ἄρσην ("male") is the Greek form of an old Proto-Indo-European word *uers-n-, with plenty of cognates in IE languages. It is actually related to the Latin verres 'ram' and other words in Sanskrit, Armenian, and Lithuanian referring to the male of an animal's species.

Meanwhile, ἄρσις comes from ἀείρω meaning "to raise up." An ἄρσις is thus a raising. The exact etymology of ἀείρω is uncertain, but Beekes reconstructs the PIE form as *h2uer-, which as you can see is a very different looking form.

θήλυς and θέσις follow a similar trajectory. The former is derived from the PIE **dheh-*, which means "to suckle." It is etymologically related to the Greek θηλή ('nipple') and the English female (from the Latin femina).

θέσις instead is derived from the verb τίθημι, and means "a placing" or a 'setting down.' It is actually where we get the English "thesis" from, as a 'topic set down [for discussion].' (Notice in fact the parallelism with the English position, from the Latin positio, meaning 'a setting down, a placing.')

So no, they're not directly related, but what might be interesting to explore is whether these were the words chosen because of their similarities to 'male' and 'female.' That I don't have an answer for, at least not without reading every place they're discussed, but I suppose it is possible.

4
  • 2
    I believe it's been proposed that the *dʰeh₁- of θήλυς and the *dʰeh₁- of τίθημι are actually the same PIE root (the semantics being "place (at the breast)" > "suckle"), so it's possible though unprovable that the latter pair are related.
    – TKR
    Oct 14 at 19:31
  • @TKR Homophones in PIE have always make me wonder if there's a connection. Do you know who published that? I didn't see it in Beekes.
    – cmw
    Oct 15 at 23:24
  • I don't, and Chantraine doesn't mention it either. Maybe someone here will know.
    – TKR
    Oct 15 at 23:42
  • 1
    @TKR Could be a good new question in itself.
    – cmw
    Oct 16 at 15:08

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.