4

I was confused on this since aren't demonstrative adjectives phrases like , "this fast" or "this large". If they are, then demonstrative adjectives not necessarily modifying nouns but adjectives, are certainly called not called a demonstrative pronoun.

1
  • I don't see what this has to with Latin. – fdb Jun 20 at 13:57
6

A pronoun is called a pronoun because it stands in place of a noun. The preposition pro in Latin means “in place of, on behalf of” (well, it is a bit more versatile, but it fits here). So a proconsul acts on behalf of a consul and a pronomen stands in for a nomen.

For example:

Marcus Claudiae obviam factus est et eam [= Claudiam] salvere iussit.
Marcus came across Claudia and greeted her [= Claudia].

Here eam (her) stands in for the noun Claudia. It would be cumbersome and irritating to repeat Claudia all the time.

This is called the substantive use of demonstrative pronouns, but they can also be used adjectively and modify nouns:

Marcus infitiatus est umquam se illam puellam vidisse.
Marcus denied ever having seen that girl.

In that case they are called adjective pronouns or pronomial adjectives. However, in Latin at least, they are still considered demonstrative pronouns.

Expressions like “this fast” or “that large” are an English peculiarity that has no direct equivalent in Latin.

1
  • It should be noted that a nomen includes both substantives (English: "nouns") and adjectives. In English as well, a noun could be adjective or substantive (though this usage is now less common). So an adjective is really a kind of nomen/noun. – Cerberus Jun 21 at 19:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.