5

One can insert the particle quippe in a relative clause to give it a causal or otherwise explaining tone.1 Does quippe require using conjunctive in the relative clause? If not, are there some rules for choosing between indicative and conjunctive that are special to quippe? Causal relative clauses usually have conjunctive, but I wonder if quippe is enough for expressing causality and the conjunctive can be omitted.

Other words can also be used to emphasize a causal nature of a relative clause: ut, utpote and praesertim. I suspect these behave like quippe as far as using conjunctive is concerned.

After reading my grammar once again while preparing this question, I am inclined to believe that conjunctive is obligatory with quippe in a relative clause, but I want to have my suspicions clearly confirmed or refuted.

This question originated from our chat room. When chatting about using three languages at the same time, I remarked: Sed crediderim id facilius esse Cerbero, quippe qui tria capita habet. Cerberus questioned my choice of indicative, and since I couldn't find a definitive answer elsewhere, I had to ask this question.


1 I have only ever seen quippe in this use. If you know other uses, please answer this question. I have explained the causal use in my answer2 to that question.

2 I may have to update that answer depending on the answer I get here.

  • This may be a dumb question, but the conjunctive and subjunctive are the same thing, right? Is there a difference in the choice of word? – Sam K Jul 22 '16 at 21:24
  • @SamK, they are the same thing. Some make a distinction between the two as you can read in this separate thread about just that, but generally they are synonymous. I always call the thing "conjunctive", but others have other habits. – Joonas Ilmavirta Jul 22 '16 at 21:28
  • @SamK, my sense (though I could be wrong) is that Latin teachers in some countries tend to teach one and in other countries tend to teach the other. – Joel Derfner Jul 22 '16 at 23:13
3

It seems that either mode was used, but each author seems to have chosen either one or the other, or both. Based on a cursory glance at the first couple of pages with quippe qui from the HP corpus, the following impressions present themselves:

Plautus uses the indicative almost exclusively.

Sallustius seems to use mainly the indicative, but also sometimes the subjunctive.

Cicero uses the subjunctive exclusively.

Livius uses the subjunctive in most cases, but sometimes the indicative.

Apuleius seems to be using both moods.

Etc.

  • Interesting! It seems that Caesar doesn't use quippe qui at all. Judging by this data, perhaps I should prefer the conjunctive for classical style, but it probably isn't a major crime to use the indicative, either. – Joonas Ilmavirta Jul 22 '16 at 21:14
  • @JoonasIlmavirta: I agree! P.S. On this site, I would say these data! – Cerberus Jul 22 '16 at 21:56

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.