8

The academic dress of a Finnish PhD looks like this:

Finnish male PhD gear

There are variants for different occasions. For example, the sword is sometimes omitted, sometimes a gown is worn instead of a white tie and ladies use a dress comparable to a white tie. If you want more details on the dress, you can have a look at these instructions about hats and swords at my university.

I am looking for a Latin word for the sword that comes with this dress. The sword is 87 cm long (blade 75 cm), weighs 730 g and looks like this:

Finnish doctoral sword

Both photos are from the pages of my university.

There are several Latin words for a sword. I found these: chalybs, copis, dolo, ensis, ensiculus/ensicula, ferrum, framea, gladius, harpe, ligula, machaera, mucro, palus/palum, rumpia, spatha, telum. Which Latin word would be most appropriate for this sword, given its appearance and use? As a side question, if academic swords are used elsewhere, what are they called in Latin?

My best guess is ensis (doctoralis), but I am no expert in swords and I would like to know if there is a better choice.

4

It seems there are quite a lot of places to look for thoughts about the various words for swords. I offer passages from three, in chronological order:

Ramshorn (1841) gives the following commentary about some of the words for "sword":

Gladius, the sword for cut and thrust; Ensis, the longer sword, more adapted for the blow or cut, hence with heroes and gigantic people: Graviter gladio caput percussit. Hirt. Stricto gladio transfigit puellam. Liv. Hectoreo perculsus concidit ense. Cic. Acinaces, the crooked Persian sabre; Sica (secare), a short cutlass used by banditti; Pugio (pungere), a stiletto, dirk; Tibi extorta est sica de manibus. Cic. Cæsare interfecto statim cruentem alte extollit Brutus pugionem. Id.

Döderlein (1858), meanwhile, gives the following:

Gladius (from κλάδος) is the usual, ensis (from ansa?) the select and poetical name for a sword. Quintil. x. 1,11. (v. 188). Pugio (from pungere) is a dagger, as a fair and openly used soldier's weapon, on a level with the sword; whereas sica (from secare) is the unfair and secret weapon of the bandit, on a level with poison.

From these, it seems that gladius would work, but ensis is perhaps less appropriate. I'd vote against both mucro and telum, as the former usually refers to the point of a sword rather than the weapon entire and the latter to any kind of weapon whatsoever.

The most specificity I've been able to find is in a translation of Aulus Gellius's Noctes Atticæ, X.25. The original reads as follows:

Telorum iaculorum gladiorumque uocabula, quae in historiis ueteribus scripta sunt, item nauigiorum genera et nomina libitum forte nobis est sedentibus in reda conquirere, ne quid aliarum ineptiarum uacantem stupentemque animum occuparet. Quae tum igitur suppetierant, haec sunt: hasta, pilum, phalarica, semiphalarica, soliferrea, gaesa, lancea, spari, rumices, trifaces, tragulae, frameae, mesanculae, cateiae, rumpiae, scorpii, sibones, siciles,
ueruta, enses, sicae, machaerae, spathae, lingulae, pugiones, clunacula.

De 'lingula', quoniam est minus frequens, admonendum existimo lingulam ueteres dixisse gladiolum oblongum in speciem linguae factum, cuius meminit Naeuius in tragoedia Hesiona. Versum Naeui apposui:

sine mi gerere morem uidear lingua, uerum lingula.

Item 'rumpia' genus teli est Thraecae nationis, positumque hoc uocabulum in Quinti Enni annalium XIV.

John Carew Rolfe (1927) gives the following translation of this passage:

Once upon a time, when I was riding in a carriage, to keep my mind from being dull and unoccupied and a prey to worthless trifles, it chanced to occur to me to try to recall the names of weapons, darts and swords which are found in the early histories, and also the various kinds of boats and their names. Those, then, of the former that came to mind at the time are the following: spear, pike, fire-pike, half-pike, iron bolt, Gallic spear, lance, hunting-darts, javelins, long bolts, barbed-javelins, German spears, thonged-javelin, Gallic bolt, broadswords, poisoned arrows, Illyrian hunting-spears, cimeters, darts, swords, daggers, broadswords, double-edged swords, small-swords, poniards, cleavers.

Of the lingula, or "little tongue," since it is less common, I think I ought to say that the ancients applied that term to an oblong small-sword, made in the form of a tongue; it is mentioned by Naevius in his tragedy Hesione. I quote the line:

Pray let me seem to please you with my tongue, But with my little tongue (lingula).

The rumpia too is a kind of weapon of the Thracian people, and the word occurs in the fourteenth book of the Annals of Quintus Ennius.

Of the terms in Rolfe's translation, "small-sword" ("a light one-handed sword designed for thrusting which evolved out of the longer and heavier rapier of the late Renaissance") seems the most appropriate for the images in your post. If he is to be trusted (I'm agnostic on the point), then lingula is probably what you want. I suppose you could add doctoralis, but given the paucity of uses one finds for the sword today that seems to me to be a touch scrupulous.

  • If gladius is the usual and ensis the select and poetical name for a sword, I am inclined towards ensis. This inclination is supported by the fact that ensis is longer and therefore closer in shape to the doctoral sword. They are both well known general words for a sword, so one of them is probably a good choice. Lingula (or spatha) are otherwise good ideas, but they might be too hard to recognize. I will accept this answer since it has contributed the most to my increase in understanding. (Apologies for being stubborn and choosing what I started with.) – Joonas Ilmavirta Aug 7 '16 at 21:49
  • Nihil ad ignoscendum est! – Joel Derfner Aug 7 '16 at 23:06
5

While the Romans did not give swords to those who became educated at a higher level (education was not as formal as it is today), they did give swords for other occasions, such as when a gladiator was freed from slavery (rudis). This does not quite fit your situation, however, so I turned to swords that looked similar. The most similar sword is the spatha, which was a similar length and used by the cavalry. enter image description here The handle of the sword is definitely different, but the style of weaponry was very different during the Roman era. I would say that adding an adjective like doctoralis makes sense (i.e. spatha doctoralis). That is about as close as you could get to what you are looking for. Ensis means sword, but in a more general sense.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.